Open mesh repair is more effective than open suture repair for incisional hernia

Clinical question: 
What is the best available open operative technique for incisional hernias?
Bottom line: 
Open mesh repair has a lower failure rate (recurrence) than open suture repair (NNT* 5 to 17), but mesh repairs are complicated by more wound infections (NNH** 12). *NNT = number needed to treat to benefit one individual. **NNH = number needed to treat to cause harm in one individual.
Six trials yielded insufficient evidence as to which type of mesh or which mesh position (below or above the fascia) should be used. In all the studies, the suture repairs were inadequately described in terms of the different possibilities in direct closure technique. Furthermore, recurrence was not objectively defined and was generally diagnosed by clinical examination rather than through imaging techniques.
Incisional hernias occur in 10 to 23 per cent of patients after abdominal operations.¹ The recurrence rate following open suture repair may be as high as 54 per cent² and as high as 32 per cent for open mesh repair.³ Several conditions are associated with the development of incisional hernia: suture technique, wound infection, increased abdominal wall tension and metabolic connective tissue disorder, specifically abdominal aortic aneurysms.⁴ 1. Cassar K, Munro A. Brit J Surg 2002; 89:534–545. 2. Paul A et al. Europ J Surg 1998; 164:361–367. 3. Burger JWA et al. Annals Surg 2004; 240:578–585. 4. Klinge V et al. Europ Surg Res 2000; 32:43–48.
Review CD#: 
October, 2008
Authored by: 
Brian R McAvoy